The question, "Can God create a stone so heavy He cannot carry?" shall be answered thus, after much deliberation by 3 philosophers in N209.
Ans: This question is faulty and the questioner's credibility suspect; the fault does not lie with God but with the question. Break the question into 2 parts -
A: Can God create... (legitimate)
B: Stone so heavy God cannot carry (invalid: no such thing; invalid set of items)...
Therefore: question cannot be answered because it is faulty - includes an invalid set of items.
A "can" or "cannot" will be a response that traps the person attempting to answer if he does not understand the fault within the question
Parallel question: "Can John do a shorbidtiadlrk?"
A: Can John do... (legitimate)
B: a shorbidtiadlrk (invalid: no such thing; invalid set of items)
Therefore, do not be unreasonable with God. Therefore, fault lies with question, not with God. Question should not be answered.